Choosing a new roof in Lakeway, Rough Hollow, Steiner Ranch or anywhere around Lake Travis usually comes down to five options. Here’s how they compare side by side, from a GAF Certified Plus contractor who installs all of them.
| Timberline HDZ | Timberline UHDZ | ArmorShield II | F-Wave XTM | Standing Seam Metal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Laminated asphalt shingle | Premium laminated asphalt shingle | SBS-modified (rubberized) asphalt shingle | Synthetic polymer shingle, made in Texas | Concealed-fastener metal panels |
| UL 2218 impact rating | Class 3 | Class 4 | Class 4 | Class 4 | Many systems Class 4 (panel & gauge dependent) |
| Look | Classic architectural | Thicker, Dual Shadow Line | Classic architectural | American Blend, Classic Slate or Hand-Split Shake | Clean, modern panel lines |
| Algae / granules | 25-yr StainGuard Plus | 30-yr StainGuard Plus PRO | 25-yr StainGuard Plus | No granules to shed | N/A |
| Wind | WindProven warranty w/ qualifying GAF accessories | WindProven warranty w/ qualifying GAF accessories | WindProven warranty w/ qualifying GAF accessories | Rated 130 mph | Excellent |
| Warranty / lifespan | Lifetime limited | Lifetime limited | Lifetime limited | Long product warranty + limited hail warranty | Often 40-70+ years |
| Relative cost | $ | $$ | $$$ | $$$ | $$$$ |
| Best for | Budget-conscious roofs | Class 4 with a premium look | Hail-prone areas & insurance discounts | Lightweight, low-maintenance, slate or shake look | Longest life, heat reflection, modern style |
Relative cost only. Every roof is priced after we carefully inspect it.
GAF Timberline HDZ
GAF’s best-selling architectural shingle and a solid, budget-friendly choice. It carries a UL 2218 Class 3 impact rating, which may qualify for a smaller insurance discount than Class 4, plus LayerLock technology, 25-year StainGuard Plus algae protection and a Lifetime limited warranty.
GAF Timberline UHDZ
GAF’s premium laminated shingle, with a thicker, more dimensional look from its Dual Shadow Line. UHDZ shingles made with GAF’s UltraMat carry a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating and a 30-year StainGuard Plus PRO algae warranty. A step up from HDZ in looks and protection. More on impact-resistant shingles.
GAF Timberline ArmorShield II
Made with SBS-modified asphalt, a rubberized formula that stays flexible and resists cracking. ArmorShield II passes the UL 2218 Class 4 impact test and is a go-to for hail-prone areas where homeowners want the classic Timberline look with the potential for insurance savings.
F-Wave XTM
A synthetic polymer shingle made in Texas, with no granules to shed and a lightweight, interlocking design. It’s UL 2218 Class 4, Class A fire rated and rated for 130 mph winds, in American Blend, Classic Slate and Hand-Split Shake styles. F-Wave offers a long product warranty and a limited hail warranty, which is rare in roofing. More on F-Wave XTM.
Standing Seam Metal
Concealed-fastener metal panels with a clean, modern look. Standing seam offers the longest lifespan of the group, excellent wind performance and heat reflection, and many panel systems carry a UL 2218 Class 4 rating depending on the panel and gauge. Large hail can leave cosmetic dents. More on standing seam metal.
How to Choose
- Budget first: Timberline HDZ.
- Best balance of looks and hail protection: Timberline UHDZ.
- Hail-prone area and insurance savings: ArmorShield II or F-Wave XTM.
- Slate or shake look without the weight: F-Wave XTM.
- Longest life and a modern look: standing seam metal.
Class 4 is the highest UL 2218 impact rating and may qualify for a lower homeowners insurance premium. Discounts vary by insurer, so check with your agent. When we install a Class 3 or Class 4 roof, we provide the impact-resistance paperwork your insurer needs. Note that most manufacturers don’t warrant shingles against hail damage; F-Wave’s limited hail warranty is the exception.
Start With a Free Inspection
Standard roof inspections are complimentary. We’ll carefully inspect your roof, then prepare and send a detailed written proposal complete with inspection photos and an inspection report. Interested in F-Wave XTM? Book an F-Wave XTM consultation. Need documentation for a home sale or insurance? Our $175 Detailed Roof Inspection includes a full written report, and the fee is refunded when you hire us for the work.
